Why Are Noise Complaints Common at Lake Rentals?

Lake house rentals in Michigan are a hot commodity during the summer. Families, graduation parties, bachelor and bachelorette groups, and reunions all flock to these rentals in June. Unfortunately, many of these events come with amplified music, bonfires, and sudden bursts of excitement — and this can lead to tension with the local community, especially if residents live there year-round.

Local residents value the peace and quiet that comes with “lake life.” Excessive noise, partying past quiet hours, or loud music echoing across the water can quickly prompt a call to the local police department or sheriff’s office.

What Michigan Law Says About Noise Complaints

State vs. Local Ordinances

Michigan doesn’t have a universal statewide noise ordinance. Instead, noise complaints are typically handled at the local level by city or township ordinances. This means the laws can vary significantly depending on where your lake house rental is located — from Charlevoix to South Haven, from Traverse City to the Keweenaw Peninsula.

Most municipalities include prohibitions on unnecessary and excessive noise, often defining “quiet hours” between 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. During this window, even moderate noise, like a Bluetooth speaker on the deck, may lead to an issue if a neighbor complains.

Misdemeanor Offense

Violating a local noise ordinance in Michigan can result in a misdemeanor charge. This can lead to:

• Fines of $100–$500 or more
• Community service hours
• Jail time in some jurisdictions
• A court appearance and a criminal record

Additionally, if you’ve rented a property and the police respond multiple times, property managers or homeowners can demand your immediate removal based on lease violations — no refund, either.

Short-Term Rental Laws and Local Pushback

Some Michigan communities are in a transitional space when it comes to short-term lake house rentals. With the rise of Airbnb and VRBO, small towns have seen a sharp increase in weekend rentals that lead to increased noise and trash. As a result, many townships have passed or are considering ordinances to tightly regulate short-term rentals.

This local pushback has a big impact. In places like Saugatuck, Petoskey, and Grand Haven, new rules often include:";

• Limitations on how often properties can be rented out
• Permitting and registration requirements
• Strict noise and nuisance enforcement policies
• Liability on the homeowner if guests cause disturbances

If you’re renting, that means you may be signing a lease agreement that includes language about evictions, fines, or immediate law enforcement reporting based on behavior. These are not just idle threats — they’re being enforced.

What Happens If the Police Show Up?

If the neighbors call the police due to excessive noise at your rental, here’s what typically happens:

• The first visit is usually a warning, assuming things are cordial and calm.
• The officer will gather names and IDs and take a report.
• If they’re called back, you may be ticketed or arrested, especially if alcohol or other violations are involved.
• Serious cases may involve disturbing the peace charges or other misdemeanor offenses.

Keep in mind — even if the homeowner didn’t tell you about a noise ordinance, it does not mean you’re off the hook. Ignorance of local laws is not a defense under Michigan law.

Common Charges Related to Noise Complaints in Michigan

Depending on the situation, a simple complaint can spiral into bigger legal trouble, particularly if alcohol or juvenile guests are part of the mix. Here are a few criminal charges that could stem from what starts as a 'noise call’:

1. Disorderly Conduct (MCL 750.167)

This catch-all includes noisy or violent behavior and can be charged as a misdemeanor. Punishable by up to 90 days in jail and/or a fine.

2. Disturbing the Peace (Local Ordinances)

Defined locally, usually carries a fine or misdemeanor charge. May also result in a civil infraction if classified as such under local law.

3. Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor (MCL 750.145)

If underage people are present, and you’re hosting or supplying alcohol, that's a serious offense in Michigan. Punishable by up to 90 days in jail and a $500 fine if convicted.

4. Hosting an Unsupervised Gathering with Alcohol

Some areas in Michigan have adopted social host ordinances. These laws make it a misdemeanor or civil infraction to allow minors to consume alcohol on your rented property — even if you didn’t supply it.

How to Prevent Noise Complaints at Your Rental

Being proactive helps avoid a visit from law enforcement. Here are some tips to stay within the good graces of Michigan’s lakeside communities:

• Know Quiet Hours: Look up local ordinances before you arrive. If you're in an HOA, know the rules and enforce them among your guests.
• Keep Music Inside: Bluetooth speakers on the deck can carry across the lake. Keep it low or bring the party indoors after dark.
• Avoid Large Parties: Many leases have a maximum number of guests. Exceeding it can be grounds for eviction and fines.
• Designate a Responsible Person: Make sure someone is monitoring noise levels and guest behavior at all times — especially at night.
• Talk to the Neighbors: If you're staying for more than a few nights, introduce yourself and offer your phone number. If an issue comes up, they’re more likely to call you first.

Taking these small steps can help you enjoy your vacation without risking a court date or a criminal charge.

What to Do If You’ve Been Charged

If your fun weekend getaway turns into a misdemeanor charge or police citation, don’t try to handle it alone. Even what seems like a minor ticket can follow you for years — especially if you're not a Michigan resident. These tickets go through local courts and often require a formal court appearance.

Some judges will allow your attorney to appear in your place, or work toward a dismissal or reduced charge. In many cases, we’ve been able to negotiate these cases down to civil infractions or dismissal if the client has no record and behaves responsibly after the incident.

Summary: Don’t Let a Noise Complaint Ruin Your Summer

Renting a lake house in Michigan can be the perfect way to enjoy your summer—don’t let legal trouble ruin it. Whether you're planning a relaxing retreat or an exciting celebration with friends, it’s important to know the rules, stay courteous to neighbors, and keep noise under control.

If the unexpected does happen and you're ticketed or charged because of a noise violation, don’t panic. Just make sure you speak with an experienced Michigan criminal defense lawyer who can work to protect your record and minimize the consequences.

Attorney Aaron J. Boria has handled hundreds of misdemeanor and ordinance violation cases throughout Michigan, and he can help you too. Call today at (734) 453-7806 to discuss your situation and start working toward a solution.