CALL FOR A FREE CONSULTATION: (734) 453-7806

Can Lack of Sleep Be a Legal Defense in Car Accident Cases? Exploring Daylight Saving Time and Drowsy Driving Risks

Daylight Saving Time (DST) has long been debated for its impact on public health and safety. One of the most significant concerns is how the time change affects sleep patterns, leading to drowsy driving and an increased risk of car accidents. But can a lack of sleep serve as a legal defense in a car accident case under Michigan law? Let’s explore how sleep deprivation, the effects of DST, and legal considerations intertwine in Michigan car accident cases.

Drowsy Driving and Michigan Law

Drowsy driving is a serious safety issue that can lead to severe accidents, injuries, and even fatalities. In Michigan, a driver can be held liable for an accident if their negligence contributed to the crash. Negligence is commonly defined as failing to exercise reasonable care while operating a vehicle.

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), drowsy driving is responsible for thousands of crashes each year. Sleep deprivation can impair judgment, slow reaction times, and negatively impact cognitive function—much like alcohol impairment.

Given these risks, Michigan law does not recognize lack of sleep as a legitimate legal defense for causing an accident. Drivers have a responsibility to ensure they are well-rested before getting behind the wheel. If someone causes a crash due to drowsy driving, they can face the same legal consequences as someone who was driving while distracted or under the influence.

How Daylight Saving Time Contributes to Drowsy Driving

Daylight Saving Time has a well-documented impact on sleep patterns. Each year, the transition leads to a temporary disruption in circadian rhythms, causing sleep deprivation for many Michigan drivers. Research suggests that in the days following the DST time change, there is a noticeable increase in car accidents.

DST-Related Crash Risks

  • Fatigue and Slower Reaction Times: Losing just one hour of sleep can significantly impair concentration and response times.
  • Increased Accident Rates: Studies have shown that in the week following the DST transition, there is an uptick in fatal crashes.
  • Workplace and Traffic Disruptions: Drowsiness affects more than just driving; it can also reduce productivity and increase errors in various job sectors.

Given these risks, drivers must take extra precautions in the days following DST to avoid drowsy driving-related accidents.

Negligence and Liability in Drowsy Driving Accidents

Under Michigan law, drivers are required to operate their vehicles safely to prevent harm to others. When a drowsy driver causes an accident, they can be held liable under Michigan’s comparative negligence standard. This means that if a driver’s inattention or fatigue caused the crash, they may be responsible for any resulting injuries or damages.

Proving Negligence in a Drowsy Driving Case

If you’ve been in an accident where drowsy driving played a role, the following factors may help establish negligence:

  • Eyewitness Testimony: Witnesses who observed erratic driving behavior before the crash can provide critical evidence.
  • Traffic Camera Footage: Video evidence might show signs of swerving or other indicators of drowsy driving.
  • Police Reports: Officers at the scene will note if the at-fault driver appeared fatigued or admitted to lack of sleep.
  • Work and Medical Records: A demanding work schedule, recent long shifts, or a diagnosed sleep disorder could suggest a driver was unfit to operate a vehicle.

Because drowsy driving is difficult to quantify—unlike drunk driving, for which there are BAC tests—proving negligence often relies on circumstantial evidence.

Can Lack of Sleep Serve as a Legal Defense?

In Michigan, lack of sleep is not a generally accepted legal defense in personal injury accidents or criminal traffic offenses. Drivers have a duty to assess their own level of fatigue before operating a vehicle. Even if a driver unintentionally fell asleep at the wheel, they can still be found negligent.

Potential Legal Consequences

Depending on the severity of the accident, penalties for drowsy driving-related crashes may include:

  • Traffic Citations: If law enforcement determines that fatigue played a role in reckless or careless driving, the driver may face fines.
  • Civil Liability: Victims of drowsy driving accidents can seek compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, and property damage.
  • Criminal Charges: If the accident results in serious injury or death, the driver could potentially face criminal charges such as involuntary manslaughter or reckless driving.

While fatigue by itself is not a defense, a driver may be able to argue that an underlying medical condition caused unexpected drowsiness—though this would require substantial medical documentation.

How to Protect Yourself from Drowsy Driving Accidents

Michigan drivers can reduce the risks of drowsy driving incidents by adopting the following precautions:

  • Get Enough Sleep: Aim for at least seven to eight hours of quality sleep daily to ensure you’re well-rested before driving.
  • Take Breaks on Long Trips: If you’re traveling long distances, schedule regular breaks to rest and stay alert.
  • Recognize the Warning Signs: If you start yawning frequently, missing road signs, or drifting between lanes, pull over and rest.
  • Avoid Driving During Peak Sleepiness Hours: Late-night and early-morning drives (between 12:00 AM and 6:00 AM) pose the highest risk for drowsy driving.

By staying proactive, you can safeguard yourself and others from the dangers of drowsy driving.

0 comments
© 2025 Boria Law.